Colonial Pizza Menu (Update 2025)
Welcome to Colonial Pizza, a cherished local gem located at 98 N Main St in Cedarville, OH. Known for its generous portions and vibrant flavors, Colonial Pizza offers a menu that caters to diverse tastes. The highlight of their offerings is the Works pizza, rich with toppings and crafted to perfection. Reviewers rave about the delicious crust, and the indulgent cheese bread that is simply unmissable.
This family-friendly establishment prides itself on exceptional service, ensuring that every visit feels special. With options like gluten-free crust and delightful chicken wings, Colonial Pizza makes every meal memorable. Many customers, like Ava H, return regularly, praising the restaurant's warm atmosphere and the quality of the food surpassing other chains.
So whether you're in the area or just passing through, be sure to stop by Colonial Pizza for a slice of happiness! You won't regret it!
Enzoani
Enzoani
A delicious turnover pizza with cheese and your choice of ingredients.
9" Special Enzoani
A delicious turnover pizza with cheese and your choice of ingredients.
12" Enzoani
A delicious turnover pizza with cheese and your choice of ingredients.
12" Special Enzoani
A delicious turnover pizza with cheese and your choice of ingredients.
Chicken Alfredo Sub (6")
Chicken - Alfredo sauce, bacon, onions, and cheese.
Italian Sausage (6")
Provolone cheese and pizza sauce.
BLT Sub (12")
Real bacon, special cheese blend, real mayo, lettuce, and tomato.
Italian Steak
Provolone cheese and pizza sauce.
Meatball Sub (12")
Provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, pizza sauce, and mayo.
Deluxe Pizza Bread Special (12")
Includes mushroom, pepperoni, sausage, onion, green peppers, and provolone cheese.
Grilled Chicken Sub (6")
Provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, and mayo.
Veggie Sub (6")
Sandy's secret pizza sauce, cheese, mild peppers, onions, mushrooms, lettuce, and tomatoes.
Veggie Sub (12")
Sandy's secret pizza sauce, cheese, mild peppers, onions, mushrooms, lettuce, and tomatoes.
Teriyaki Chicken (12")
Chicken, teriyaki glaze, provolone cheese, lettuce, and tomato.
Colonial Steak (6")
Provolone cheese and mushroom gravy.
Colonial Sub (12")
Baked ham, cooked salami, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, and mild peppers.
Pot Roast Sub (6")
Lettuce, tomato, mayo, provolone, and au jus.
BBQ Steak Sub (12")
BBQ sauce, onion, bacon, cheddar cheese, and provolone cheese.
Baked Ham (12")
Provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, and mayo.
Pizza Sub (6")
Pepperoni, provolone cheese, and pizza sauce.
Greek Gyro Sub (6")
Pita bread, gyro meat, tzatziki sauce, onion, tomatoes, and black olives.
Colonial Steak (12")
Provolone cheese and mushroom gravy.
Taco Sub (6")
Taco meat, sour cream, lettuce, cheddar cheese, and tomato.
Baked Ham (6")
Provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, and mayo.
Deluxe Pizza Bread Special (6")
Includes mushroom, pepperoni, sausage, onion, green peppers, and provolone cheese.
Pizza Bread Special (6")
Pepperoni, provolone cheese, and pizza sauce.
BBQ Steak Sub (6")
BBQ sauce, onion, bacon, cheddar cheese, and provolone cheese.
Turkey Breast (12")
Provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato and mayo.
Club Sub (12")
Turkey breast, baked ham, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, and mayo.
Chicken Bacon Ranch (6")
Chicken, bacon, ranch dressing, lettuce, and tomato.
Pizza Sub (12")
Pepperoni, provolone cheese, and pizza sauce.
Taco Sub (12")
Taco meat, sour cream, lettuce, cheddar cheese, and tomato.
Italian Sub (12")
Cooked salami, spiced loaf, bologna, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, and mild peppers.
Pot Roast Sub (12")
Lettuce, tomato, mayo, provolone, and au jus.
BLT Sub (6")
Real bacon, special cheese blend, real mayo, lettuce, and tomato.
Grilled Chicken Sub (12")
Provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, and mayo.
Pizza Bread Special (12")
Pepperoni, provolone cheese, and pizza sauce.
Chicken Alfredo Sub (12")
Chicken - Alfredo sauce, bacon, onions, and cheese.
Buffalo Chicken Sub (12")
Hot sauce, chicken, buttermilk, and cheese.
Meatball Sub (6")
Provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, pizza sauce, and mayo.
Buffalo Chicken Sub (6")
Hot sauce, chicken, buttermilk, and cheese.
Teriyaki Chicken (6")
Chicken, teriyaki glaze, provolone cheese, lettuce, and tomato.
Italian Sausage (12")
Provolone cheese and pizza sauce.
Turkey Breast (6")
Provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato and mayo.
Colonial Sub (6")
Baked ham, cooked salami, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, and mild peppers.
Italian Sub (6")
Cooked salami, spiced loaf, bologna, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, and mild peppers.
Chicken Bacon Ranch (12")
Chicken, bacon, ranch dressing, lettuce, and tomato.
Club Sub (6")
Turkey breast, baked ham, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, and mayo.
Oven Baked Subs
Salads
Southwest Salad
Includes salad mixture, grilled chicken breast, cheese blend, onions, mild peppers, and tomato.
Side Salad
Salad mixture and tomatoes.
Buffalo Chicken Salad
Hot sauce, chicken, buttermilk, and cheese.
Greek Salad
Includes spring mix, onion, black olives, tomatoes, feta cheese, and raspberry vinaigrette.
Antipasto
Includes salad mixture, cheese blend, pepperoni, onion, tomatoes, mild peppers, and Sandy's Italian dressing.
Asian Salad
Includes spring mix, red cabbage, craisins, almonds, rice noodles, breaded chicken, and Asian dressing.
Taco Salad
Includes lettuce, nacho chips, cheddar cheese, sour cream, tomato, and taco meat.
Chef Salad
Includes salad mixture, baked ham, cheddar cheese, and tomato.
Gatorade
Bottle of punch or blue flavor Gatorade.
2 Ltr Bottles
Your favorite flavor of soda, in a 2 ltr bottle.
Soda Cans
Your favorite flavor of canned sodas.
Water
20 oz bottle of water.
16 Oz Fountain Soda
16 oz fountain sodas available: Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Sierra Mist, Dr. Pepper, Mug Root Beer, Fruit Punch, Pink Lemonade, Mountain Dew, and Diet Mountain Dew.
32 Oz Fountain Soda
32 oz fountain sodas available: Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Sierra Mist, Dr. Pepper, Mug Root Beer, Fruit Punch, Pink Lemonade, Mountain Dew, and Diet Mountain Dew.
Drinks
Appetizers
Nachos With Jalapeno
Delicious fresh chips served with cheese dip.
Tots With Cheese & Bacon
Delicious tater tots with cheese and bacon.
Killer Wings
Delicious wings with a variety of sauces.
Tasty Tots
Delicious tater tots
Boneless Chicken Wings
1lb of wings
Breadsticks
Garlic topped, with optional cheese.
Mozzarella Sticks
Served with pizza sauce.
Extra Sauces
Breadsticks Basket
Garlic topped, with optional cheese.
Potato Skins
Sour cream, cheddar cheese and bacon.
Nachos With Cheese
Delicious fresh chips served with cheese dip.
Manicotti A La Carte
Delicious Manicotti.
Manicotti With Salad
Delicious Manicotti.
Baked Lasagna A La Carte
Delicious Baked Lasagna.
Spaghetti With Salad
Delicious Spaghetti.
Spaghetti A La Carte
Delicious Spaghetti.
Baked Lasagna With Salad
Delicious Baked Lasagna.
Spaghetti With Alfredo
Delicious Spaghetti in Alfredo Sauce, With a Salad.
Italian Dishes
Pizza
Deep Dish Pizza (18 Inch)
Deep Dish Pizza (12 Inch)
Cheese Party Pizza (24 Inch)
Gluten-Free Pizza
10" Gluten-Free.
Cheese Pizza (7 Inch)
Deep Dish Pizza (9 Inch)
Cheese Pizza (15 Inch)
Cheese Pizza (18 Inch)
Cheese Pizza (12 Inch)
Deep Dish Pizza (7 Inch)
Cheese Pizza (9 Inch)
Deep Dish Pizza (15 Inch)
Pies & Cakes
Pies and cakes offered in a variety of flavors.
Cookies
Delicious fresh cookies.
Brownies
Desserts
Special Pizzas
Taco Pizza (24 Inch)
Taco meat, shredded cheese, lettuce, tomato. Sour cream and salsa on the side
Chicken Alfredo Pizza (12 Inch)
Chicken - Alfredo sauce, bacon, onions, and cheese.
Garden Salad Pizza (7 Inch)
Buttermilk dressing, broccoli, mushrooms, green peppers, onions, tomatoes, black olives and special blend cheeses.
Margherita Pizza (12 Inch)
Filleted steamed tomatoes, garlic, sliced mozzarella, virgin olive oil and topped with Romano and parmesan spiced cheese.
Margherita Pizza (18 Inch)
Filleted steamed tomatoes, garlic sliced mozzarella, virgin olive oil and topped with Romano and parmesan spiced cheese.
Chicken Bacon Ranch (12 Inch)
Chicken, bacon, spinach, onions, ranch dressing.
Hawaiian (24 Inch)
Pizza sauce, baked ham, bacon, pineapple, cheese
Chicken Bacon Ranch (15 Inch)
Chicken, bacon, spinach, onions, ranch dressing.
Greek Pizza (12 Inch)
Tzatziki sauce, gyro meat, onions, black olives, tomatoes, feta cheese and four cheese blend.
Big Meat Pizza (9 Inch)
Sandy's pizza sauce, special blend cheese, pepperoni, baked ham, Italian sausage, bacon and hamburger.
Deluxe Special Pizza (7 Inch)
Sandy's pizza sauce, cheese blend, mushrooms, pepperoni, Italian sausage, onion and green peppers.
Margherita (24 Inch)
Filleted steamed tomatoes, sliced mozzarella, garlic olive oil, topped with Romano and Parmesan cheese
Mac N Cheese Pizza (15 Inch)
White cheddar Mac n cheese cheese blend garlic butter
Greek Pizza (7 Inch)
Tzatziki sauce, gyro meat, onions, black olives, tomatoes, feta cheese and four cheese blend.
Big Meat Pizza (18 Inch)
Sandy's pizza sauce, special blend cheese, pepperoni, baked ham, Italian sausage, bacon and hamburger.
Margherita Pizza (15 Inch)
Filleted steamed tomatoes, garlic, sliced mozzarella, virgin olive oil and topped with Romano and parmesan spiced cheese.
Big Meat Pizza (15 Inch)
Sandy's pizza sauce, special blend cheese, pepperoni, baked ham, Italian sausage, bacon and hamburger.
Vegetarian's Delight Pizza (9 Inch)
Sandy's secret pizza sauce, special blend cheese, tomatoes, onions, green peppers, mushrooms, black olives and pineapples.
BBQ Chicken Pizza (12 Inch)
Chicken, sweet baby ray's BBQ sauce, bacon and onions.
Chicken Bacon Ranch (9 Inch)
Chicken, bacon, spinach, onions, ranch dressing.
Garden Salad Pizza (9 Inch)
Buttermilk dressing, broccoli, mushrooms, green peppers, onions, tomatoes, black olives and special blend cheeses.
BBQ Chicken Pizza (18 Inch)
Chicken, sweet baby ray's BBQ sauce, bacon and onions.
Big Meat Pizza (7 Inch)
Sandy's pizza sauce, special blend cheese, pepperoni, baked ham, Italian sausage, bacon and hamburger.
Deluxe Special Pizza (9 Inch)
Sandy's pizza sauce, cheese blend, mushrooms, pepperoni, Italian sausage, onion and green peppers.
BBQ Chicken Pizza (9 Inch)
Chicken, sweet baby ray's BBQ sauce, bacon and onions.
Garden Salad Pizza (15 Inch)
Buttermilk dressing, broccoli, mushrooms, green peppers, onions, tomatoes, black olives and special blend cheeses.
Vegetarian's Delight Pizza (7 Inch)
Sandy's secret pizza sauce, special blend cheese, tomatoes, onions, green peppers, mushrooms, black olives and pineapples.
Buffalo Chicken Pizza (15 Inch)
Hot sauce, chicken, buttermilk dressing, and cheese.
Big Meat Pizza (12 Inch)
Sandy's pizza sauce, special blend cheese, pepperoni, baked ham, Italian sausage, bacon and hamburger.
Deluxe Special Pizza (12 Inch)
Sandy's pizza sauce, cheese blend, mushrooms, pepperoni, Italian sausage, onion and green peppers.
Deluxe (24 Inch)
Pizza sauce, Pepperoni, sausage, mushroom, onion, green pepper
Buffalo Chicken Pizza (18 Inch)
Hot sauce, chicken, buttermilk dressing, and cheese.
Caliente Beef Pizza (12 Inch)
Crushed red pepper relish, jalapeno peppers, onions, beef, cheddar cheese, four-cheese blend, tomato and sour cream.
Taco Pizza (7 Inch)
Home-style taco meat, cheddar cheese, lettuce, sour cream and tomatoes.
Caliente Chicken Pizza (7 Inch)
Crushed red pepper relish, jalapeno peppers, onions, chicken, cheddar cheese, four-cheese blend, tomato and sour cream.
Chicken Alfredo (24 Inch)
Alfredo sauce with onion and bacon, chicken, cheese. (Onion and bacon are in the sauce and cannot be removed)
Garden Salad Pizza (18 Inch)
Buttermilk dressing, broccoli, mushrooms, green peppers, onions, tomatoes, black olives and special blend cheeses.
Buffalo Chicken Pizza (12 Inch)
Hot sauce, chicken, buttermilk dressing, and cheese.
BLT (24 Inch)
Bacon, cheese, mayonnaise, lettuce, tomato
Vegetarian (24 Inch)
Pizza sauce, mushroom, onion, green pepper, black olives, tomato, pineapple
Taco Pizza (15 Inch)
Home-style taco meat, cheddar cheese, lettuce, sour cream and tomatoes.
Margherita Pizza (7 Inch)
Filleted steamed tomatoes, garlic, sliced mozzarella, virgin olive oil and topped with Romano and parmesan spiced cheese.
Caliente Beef Pizza (7 Inch)
Crushed red pepper relish, jalapeno peppers, onions, beef, cheddar cheese, four-cheese blend, tomato and sour cream.
Kitchen Sink (24 Inch)
Pizza sauce, mushroom, pepperoni, ham, bacon, onion, green pepper, black olives, hamburger, mild peppers, cheese
Garlic Pizza (7 Inch)
Garlic butter, chicken, bacon, onions, tomatoes, broccoli.
Caliente Chicken Pizza (18 Inch)
Crushed red pepper relish, jalapeno peppers, onions, chicken, cheddar cheese, four-cheese blend, tomato and sour cream.
BBQ Chicken Pizza (15 Inch)
Chicken, sweet baby ray's BBQ sauce, bacon and onions.
Mac N Cheese Pizza (12 Inch)
White cheddar Mac n cheese cheese blend garlic butter
Buffalo Chicken Pizza (9 Inch)
Hot sauce, chicken, buttermilk dressing, and cheese.
Deluxe Special Pizza (15 Inch)
Sandy's pizza sauce, cheese blend, mushrooms, pepperoni, Italian sausage, onion and green peppers.
Greek Pizza (9 Inch)
Tzatziki sauce, gyro meat, onions, black olives, tomatoes, feta cheese and four cheese blend.
Vegetarian's Delight Pizza (15 Inch)
Sandy's secret pizza sauce, special blend cheese, tomatoes, onions, green peppers, mushrooms, black olives and pineapples.
Caliente Chicken Pizza (15 Inch)
Crushed red pepper relish, jalapeno peppers, onions, chicken, cheddar cheese, four-cheese blend, tomato and sour cream.
Chicken Bacon Ranch (18 Inch)
Chicken, bacon, spinach, onions, ranch dressing.
Caliente Beef (24 Inch)
Crushed Red pepper relish, jalapeno peppers, onion, chuck beef, cheddar cheese, cheese blend, tomato. Sour cream on the side
Caliente Chicken Pizza (9 Inch)
Crushed red pepper relish, jalapeno peppers, onions, chicken, cheddar cheese, four-cheese blend, tomato and sour cream.
Kitchen Sink Pizza
Hamburger, mushrooms, pepperoni, ham, bacon, onion, green peppers, black olives and mild banana peppers.
Mac N Cheese Pizza (7 Inch)
White cheddar Mac n cheese cheese blend garlic butter.
Garlic Pizza (9 Inch)
Garlic butter, chicken, bacon, onions, tomatoes, broccoli.
BLT Pizza (7 Inch)
Real bacon, special cheese blend, real mayo, lettuce and tomato.
Greek(24 Inch)
Tatziki sauce, gyro meat, feta cheese, onion, black olives, tomato, cheese
Chicken Alfredo Pizza (9 Inch)
Chicken - Alfredo sauce, bacon, onions, and cheese.
Garlic Pizza (15 Inch)
Garlic butter, chicken, bacon, onions, tomatoes, broccoli.
Mac N Cheese Pizza (18 Inch)
White cheddar Mac n cheese cheese blend garlic butter
Chicken Alfredo Pizza (7 Inch)
Chicken - Alfredo sauce, bacon, onions, and cheese.
Chicken Bacon Ranch (7 Inch)
Chicken, bacon, spinach, onions, ranch dressing.
Buffalo Chicken Pizza (24 Inch)
Buffalo sauce, ranch, chicken, cheese
Greek Pizza (18 Inch)
Tzatziki sauce, gyro meat, onions, black olives, tomatoes, feta cheese and four cheese blend.
Caliente Chicken (24 Inch)
Crushed Red pepper relish, jalapeno peppers, onions, chicken, cheddar cheese, cheese blend, tomato. Sour cream on the side
Garden Salad Pizza (12 Inch)
Buttermilk dressing, broccoli, mushrooms, green peppers, onions, tomatoes, black olives and special blend cheeses.
BBQ Chicken (24 Inch)
BBQ sauce, chicken, bacon, onion, cheese
Caliente Beef Pizza (9 Inch)
Crushed red pepper relish, jalapeno peppers, onions, beef, cheddar cheese, four-cheese blend, tomato and sour cream.
Deluxe Special Pizza (18 Inch)
Sandy's pizza sauce, cheese blend, mushrooms, pepperoni, Italian sausage, onion and green peppers.
BLT Pizza (18 Inch)
Real bacon, special cheese blend, real mayo, lettuce and tomato.
Caliente Chicken Pizza (12 Inch)
Crushed red pepper relish, jalapeno peppers, onions, chicken, cheddar cheese, four-cheese blend, tomato and sour cream.
Chicken Alfredo Pizza (15 Inch)
Chicken - Alfredo sauce, bacon, onions, and cheese.
Garden (24 Inch)
Ranch dressing, mushroom, onion, green pepper, broccoli, black olives, tomato
Greek Pizza (15 Inch)
Tzatziki sauce, gyro meat, onions, black olives, tomatoes, feta cheese and four cheese blend.
BLT Pizza (15 Inch)
Real bacon, special cheese blend, real mayo, lettuce and tomato.
Taco Pizza (9 Inch)
Home-style taco meat, cheddar cheese, lettuce, sour cream and tomatoes.
Big Meat (24 Inch)
Pizza sauce, Pepperoni, sausage, bacon, baked ham, Chuck beef
Caliente Beef Pizza (18 Inch)
Crushed red pepper relish, jalapeno peppers, onions, beef, cheddar cheese, four-cheese blend, tomato and sour cream.
Caliente Beef Pizza (15 Inch)
Crushed red pepper relish, jalapeno peppers, onions, beef, cheddar cheese, four-cheese blend, tomato and sour cream.
Chicken Alfredo Pizza (18 Inch)
Chicken - Alfredo sauce, bacon, onions, and cheese.
Vegetarian's Delight Pizza (12 Inch)
Sandy's secret pizza sauce, special blend cheese, tomatoes, onions, green peppers, mushrooms, black olives and pineapples.
Chicken Bacon Ranch (24 Inch)
Ranch, chicken, Onion, spinach, bacon, cheese
Mac N Cheese Pizza (9 Inch)
White cheddar Mac n cheese cheese blend garlic butter
Buffalo Chicken Pizza (7 Inch)
Hot sauce, chicken, buttermilk dressing, and cheese.
BBQ Chicken Pizza (7 Inch)
Chicken, sweet baby ray's BBQ sauce, bacon and onions.
Garlic Pizza (12 Inch)
Garlic butter, chicken, bacon, onions, tomatoes, broccoli.
Garlic (24 Inch)
Garlic butter, Chicken, bacon, onion, tomato, broccoli, cheese
BLT Pizza (9 Inch)
Real bacon, special cheese blend, real mayo, lettuce and tomato.
Mac N Cheese (24 Inch)
Garlic butter, creamy macaroni and cheese, cheese blend
BLT Pizza (12 Inch)
Real bacon, special cheese blend, real mayo, lettuce and tomato.
Vegetarian's Delight Pizza (18 Inch)
Sandy's secret pizza sauce, special blend cheese, tomatoes, onions, green peppers, mushrooms, black olives and pineapples.
Taco Pizza (12 Inch)
Home-style taco meat, cheddar cheese, lettuce, sour cream and tomatoes.
Margherita Pizza (9 Inch)
Filleted steamed tomatoes, garlic, sliced mozzarella, virgin olive oil and topped with Romano and parmesan spiced cheese.
Taco Pizza (18 Inch)
Home-style taco meat, cheddar cheese, lettuce, sour cream and tomatoes.
Garlic Pizza (18 Inch)
Garlic butter, chicken, bacon, onions, tomatoes, broccoli.